What is better to use with Xandadeck, a PC monitor or a TV set?

Let’s see some pros and cons.

TV Sets

Pros

  • TVs come in large sizes. It is relatively cheap to get a 32″-55″ sized TV set.
  • Almost all TVs have HDMI inputs, so it is easy to connect them to a Xandabox (or any other type of player).
  • TVs also have speakers, so you can also use audio.

Cons

  • TVs (up to 24″) are generally more expensive than computer monitors.
  • TVs cannot be powered off simply by deactivating the display port (HDMI/VGA/DVI port).
  • Some TVs (e.g. LG) cannot be powered off at all, even via HDMI-CEC. So, you cannot power them off easily. See the HDMI-CEC vendor compatibility matrix.
  • TVs have remotes. In case you want to leave them unattended, you must deactivate the remote receiver, or a prankster might use a remote to fool around.

Computer Monitors

Pros

  • Computer monitors are cheap, cheaper than TV sets, especially below the 24″ size range.
  • Most units tend to be lighter than TV sets.
  • There are no remotes, so it is not easy for someone to play around with the monitor.
  • All computer monitors support power on/off.

Cons

  • Computer monitors generally do not have speakers.
  • Computer monitors larger than 24″ are usually more expensive than TV sets. And more rare. It is difficult to find a computer monitor larger than 32″, and if you do, it is insanely expensive.
  • Not all computer monitors have HDMI inputs. So, you might need a HDMI-to-DVI adapter to connect a Xandabox to them. (VGA-only monitors are now rare, so let’s skip them)

Conclusion


If you have a new installation, then we suggest:

  • Computer monitors, if you need up to 24″ in size (with or without speakers, depending on your needs)
  • TV sets, if you need panels larger than 24″, but make sure that the vendors supports Power On/Off via HDMI-CEC. See the HDMI-CEC vendor compatibility matrix.  
Administrator

Leave your comment